Triple Whammy Triple Chocolate Lactation Cookie Recipe (2024)

Created On: December 10, 2021&nbsp|Updated: December 10, 2021|By Amanda | 12 Comments

This Triple Whammy Triple Chocolate Lactation Cookie recipe has three milk making ingredients to help you pump more breast milk!

This post may contain affiliate links, which means that if you click through and make a purchase, I’ll be compensated at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products I love! More info here.

I LOVE chocolate! I was super excited to make a chocolate chocolate chip lactation cookie.

I found this recipe to use as a starting point, and then started making changes to add galactagogues. The goal for every lactation cookie recipe I make is to get three galactagogues (oatmeal, brewer’s yeast, and flax seed) into the the recipe, and to get as much as you can into it without affecting the taste. This starting recipe already had oatmeal, so I just modified a few things to work in the other two.

You guys, these are delicious. My kids love them, and honestly I’m a little worried that my 8 year old boy might start lactating because he’s been eating so many.

One note – the dough for this recipe is really sticky, so I would highly recommend using a cookie scoop (the tablespoon size) if you have one.

Some common questions:

Do lactation cookies really work?

This question is hard to answer. Some women experience an increase in milk supply when eating lactation cookies, and others don’t. (Milk supply is so individual – different things work for different women at different times in their breastfeeding “careers.”)

For women who do see a supply, the increase could be due to either or both of the following:

• The galactagogues in the cookies (in this case, oatmeal, brewer’s yeast, and flax seed), or
• The placebo effect (the mental confidence from doing something you think will make a difference)

My opinion: why not try it? The cookies are delicious, your whole family can eat them, and there’s a decent chance you’ll pump a little more milk!

What if I don’t have brewer’s yeast?

If you don’t have brewer’s yeast, the easiest way is usually to get it on amazon.

If that’s not possible, then skip the brewer’s yeast and use 1 1/4 cups of flour instead of 1 cup of flour and 1/4 cup brewer’s yeast. You can still benefit from the oatmeal and flax seed.

What if I don’t have flax seed?

Most grocery stores have ground flax seed, but if you’re not able to get it, you can skip it.

What if I need a gluten-free or egg-free version?

A reader (Kati Cole) adapted this lactation cookie recipe to be gluten-free and egg-free! You can download a PDF with the adjusted recipe here. Thank you Kati!

Can I freeze these lactation cookies for later?

Yes. You can freeze them flat on a baking sheet or plate or something. Then, once frozen, you can transfer the cookies to a container for storage.

Can I freeze this lactation cookie dough and make them later?

Yes. I tested freezing the dough in a plastic zip-top bag, defrosting, and baking, and the cookies turned out fine!

Enjoy!